Parent-Child Interactions with ADHD Children: Significance
of Parental Empathy in Child Adjustment
Shelly Warren and Trish Kaminski
Much attention has been paid in research and therapy to negative cycles
of interaction between parent and child, which are thought to play a crucial
role in the development and maintenance of child behavior problems. However,
it is equally important to consider how positive family interactions can
be promoted, as these are likely to help prevent or reduce behavior problems.
The purpose of this study is to investigate the relationship between parental
empathy and child adjustment factors in children with Attention-Deficit/Hyperactivity
Disorder (ADHD). Specifically, it is hypothesized that higher levels of
parent empathy will predict higher levels of child self-esteem, social
skills, and behavioral compliance, and lower levels of child aggression.
If this relationship can be verified, it will have important implications
for the treatment of children with ADHD, who often experience difficulties
in interactions with their parents.
Parent-Child Relations and Peer Relations
in Children with ADHD
Sarah Durrant and Trish Kaminski
Research has shown that poor peer relationships are predictive of negative
outcomes in adolescence and early adulthood (i.e., school dropout and
criminal behavior) (for a review, see Parker & Asher, 1987). Further,
developmental research has posited that parents indirectly influence children's
peer functioning through aspects of the parent-child relationship (e.g.,
Armentrout, 1972; Carson & Parke, 1996; Harrist, Pettit, Dodge, & Bates,
1994). One specific group of children that exhibit significant problems
with peers (Henker & Whalen, 1999) and in interactions with parents (Danforth,
Barkley, & Stokes, 1991) is children diagnosed with Attention-Deficit/Hyperactivity
Disorder (ADHD). The purpose of the study is to determine if there is
a significant association between parent-child relationship characteristics
and peer acceptance in an ADHD population. If family-peer links are found
in children with ADHD, this will indicate the importance of focusing peer
problem interventions not only on social skills training, but also on
improving aspects of the parent-child relationship.
Self-Concept of Children with ADHD
Kim Barton and Trish Kaminski.
Children with ADHD and matched controls are interviewed after being shown
the video recording of their recent PCIA interaction with their parents. The
interview is transcribed and inferences are drawn about the child's self-concept
based upon the child's answers to questions about what the child is doing,
thinking, feelings, and wanting.
Mothers and Daughters with ADHD
Sara Weisenbach and Trish Kaminski
Parent-Child Psychopathology: ADHD Children and Depressed/Anxious
Parents
Investigators: Katie Besly and Trish Kaminski. Top
Depression
Direct Observation of School Aged Children with Depressed and
Nondepressed Mothers
Janel Burchfield and Rick Holigrocki Children of depressed parents are at risk for behavioral and
emotional difficulties as well as for developing later psychopathology.
Some children, however, do not show evidence of dysfunction. The nature
and pattern of the interaction of depressed and nondepressed parents and
their children is described. Children of depressed parents are expected
to show a range of responses and post hoc qualitative exploratory analysis
will be conducted to understand what risk and protective factors may account
for resiliency and dysfunction.
Depressed and Nondepressed Mothers
Danielle Bach and Rick Holigrocki How does maternal depression affect the nature of parents' interaction
with their children? Although the impact of maternal depression on infants
has been well documented, there are a limited number of direct observation
studies of depressed mothers with preschoolers and school age children.
This study will examine the actual interactions between children and parents
with Major Depressive Disorder and/or Dysthymic Disorder. Using a nondepressed
control group for comparison, researchers will test hypothesis relating
to the communication and behaviors of parent-child dyads when the mother
is depressed. Top
Oppositional Defiant Disorder/Conduct Disorder
Children with Disruptive Behavior Disorders: Internal Representations
and Behaviors with Parents
Christine Raches and Rick Holigrocki The study examines the relationship between a child's internal
representational world, as inferred by the Rorschach and the TAT, and
a child's behaviors during a play task with the parent. This research
is being conducted with a sample of mothers and their 7- to 10-year-old
children in which the child has been diagnosed with a disruptive behavior
disorder and age- and gender-matched control dyads. Each dyad is filmed
as they complete the Parent-Child Interaction Assessment. The behavior
codes of interest are Child Aggression and Compliance. Upon completion
of the PCIA-II, the child is then given the Rorschach and the TAT. The
Rorschach is scored using the Mutuality of Autonomy Scale (Urist, 1977),
which involves evaluating all movement responses on an ordinal scale ranging
from empathic relatedness to malevolence. The TAT is coded using the Social
Cognitions and Object Relations Scale (1985, Westen, Lohr, Silk, Kerber,
& Goodrich) which measures the complexity of representations, affect tone
of relationship paradigms, emotional investment in relationships, and
understanding of social causality. Data are also collected for descriptive
purposes on parent and child psychopathology, parenting style, and child
intelligence. Object relations theory is used to describe the relationship
between the children's internal representations and their behaviors with
their parents.
Disruptive Behavior: Sequential Analysis
Sarah Rains and Rick Holigrocki
Attributions and Role Reversals of Children with Disruptive Behavior
Disorders
Yvonne Bohr, York University, Canada
This study is of parents and 4- to 6-year-old children with disruptive
behavior disorder, conduct disorder, and/or ADHD.
Projection and Observed Aggression in Children with and without
Conduct Problems
Rick Holigrocki and Robbi Hudson-Crain
The use of defense mechanisms and observed physical aggression by male
and female 7- to 10-year old children with conduct problems (CP) were
compared to children with no conduct problems (NCP). Children completed
the Thematic Apperception Test (Murray, 1943) and were filmed with
their parents as they completed the Parent-Child Interaction Assessment-II
(PCIA-II; Holigrocki, Kaminski, & Frieswyk, 1999, 2002). The TAT responses
were coded for defenses using the Defense Mechanisms Manual (DMM; Cramer,
1991); and the video recordings were coded for children’s physical aggression.
Top
Personality Disorders and Character Traits
Narcissistic Traits and Parenting Style: A Closer Look at Maladaptive
Parenting Through Parent-Child Observations, Parent Self-Report, and Child
Self-Report
Michelle Collins and Trish Kaminski The thrust of this investigation is to examine the relationship
between narcissistic traits in mothers and several variables associated
with parenting efficacy. Approximately 200 mothers will complete a battery
of measures, including the Adult-Adolescent Parenting Inventory-2, Childhood
Trauma Questionnaire, Child Abuse Potential, and the MCMI-III (Narcissistic
scale). Variables hypothesized to be associated with maternal narcissism
include parental empathy, inappropriate expectations of children, disciplining
style, and parent-child role-reversal. Moreover, mothers' expressions
of nurturance, positive personal comments, and negative personal comments
towards their children are also hypothesized to be related to narcissism
and will be assessed through coding of video recorded interactions on the
Parent-Child Interaction Assessment-II (PCIA-II; Holigrocki, Kaminski,
& Frieswyk, 2002). Other relationships under study include associations
between maternal narcissism and personal abuse history, child abuse potential,
and children's perceptions of maternal rejection. Finally, the factor
structure of the MCMI-III will be analyzed, given the emphasis within
the recent literature on narcissism as a multi-dimensional construct.
Understanding the construct of narcissism and its relationship to parent-child
interactions and children's perceptions of parental acceptance could have
important implications for children's healthy development and parenting
interventions. Top
Cross Cultural Research
Hong Kong and European-American Mother-Child Interaction
Daphne Au Young and Rick Holigrocki How are Hong Kong and European-American mother-child interactions
similar or different? This research is exploratory and has implications
for assisting professionals in the fields of mental health, education,
and health sciences in learning to understand cross-cultural differences
in parenting. Ms. Au Young travelled to Hong Kong in August 2003 and collected
PCIA-II data at the Hong Kong Baptist University. With the assistance
of undergraduate research assistants in Canada, Ms. Au Young is transcribing
the video recordings and translating them from Cantonese to English. She will
be comparing her Hong Kong sample to a community sample collected in Indianapolis. Top
Posttraumatic Play
Sequelae of Child Sexual Abuse: A Child and Parent Assessment Rick Holigrocki and Christine Raches
We present a case example of a 9-year-old, biracial girl and her mother.
We integrate data collected from rating scales (e.g., Child Behavior Checklist; Achenbach
& Rescorla, 2001), a free response measure (Thematic Apperception
Test; Murray, 1943), and a direct observation measure (Parent-Child Interaction
Assessment-II; Holigrocki, Kaminski, & Frieswyk, 1999, 2002) and reveal how a child sexual abuse victim’s internal representations
and symptoms manifest in both an interpersonal context and in the realm
of play. We discuss assessment findings regarding how they provide
for an idiographic understanding of the child (Journal of Personality
Assessment, April 2006). [PDF159 kb] Top
Relational Psychopathology
A Structural and Microanalytic Exploration of Parent-Child Relational
Psychopathology Investigators
Rick Holigrocki and Trish Kaminski A videotape of a parent and child playing is used to illustrate
the relational expression of psychopathology and how internal representations
of a parent may be transferred to a child. The dyad's verbalizations and
behaviors are understood as expressions of an underlying organization
of tacitly held assumptions of self and other experiences. The case presented
is of a 25-year-old mother with dependent personality characteristics
and her dysfunctional interactions with her 7-year-old daughter. Descriptive
data were drawn from a battery of objective tests and the structural analysis
was performed on the videotaped interactions of the dyad completing the
Parent-Child Interaction Assessment This paper is based upon our presentation
at the Society for Personality Assessment (Published in Constructivism
in the Human Sciences). [PDF147 kb] Top
Victim-Victimizer Relational Dynamics as Maintained by Representational,
Defensive, and Neurobiologic Functioning
Rick Holigrocki and Robbi Hudson-Crain Cognitive-affective, defensive, and neurobiologic aspects of
victim-victimizer relational dynamics are illustrated. Observations of
a 26-year-old mother and her 9-year-old son during a social pretend play
task and projective and objective assessment data provide the sources
of inference regarding how the parent and child’s thematic structures
are relationally expressed, maintain their psychopathology, and foster
a victim-victimizer interactional cycle. By way of complimentary interpersonal,
psychological, and neurobiologic processes, a victim-victimizer relational
dynamic is maintained and intergenerationally transmitted (Published in
the Bulletin of the Menninger Clinic). [PDF168 kb] Top
Scale Development
Child Aggression Scale
Trish Kaminski
Global Assessment of Parental Attunement
Trish Kaminski, Rick Holigrocki, and Shelly Warren
Disruption of Play
Rick Holigrocki and Shira Louria
Observation Coding System
Trish Kaminski
Transcript Coding System
Rick Holigrocki, Sid Frieswyk, Chuck Fantz and Jim Taylor, Trish Kaminski,
Danielle Bach, Janel Perkins, Sarah Rains, Lisa Settles, & Christine
Shuttz (Last five co-authors listed in alphabetical order) PCIA-II video recordings of high-risk and control parent-child dyads
were used to generate codes. Codes include variables such as nurturance,
aggression, limit setting, asking, suggesting, commanding, complying,
oppositionality, etc. A manual has been developed that describes each
code. Transcription instructions are also included in the manual.
Treatment
Changing Parent Attributions in High Risk Families
Yvonne Bohr This article describes one child and family treatment center's
process of creating a long-awaited, new infant/child early intervention
program. An experimental service model is discussed in the context of
the need for empirically validated assessment and intervention for very
young clients in high-risk families. Case examples and illustrations of
service flow are provided. Some features of this program, such as the
fact that it was set up for a seamless transition to a treatment research
project, are highlighted. Citation: Bohr, Y. (2005). Infant Mental Health
Programs: Experimenting with innovative models. Infant Mental Health
Journal, 26(5), 407-422.
Women Victims of Domestic Violence: Modifying Attributions using
the PCIA-II MAP Intervention
Rick Holigrocki The study involves the evaluation of an intervention for mothers who have been victims of domestic violence.
The intervention, designed by Bohr (2005, 2004a, 2004b), targets and modify a mother’s faulty
parental attributions regarding her child. Method. Forty
mothers and their 7- to 10-year-old children will be randomly assigned to a waitlist or treatment group. They are filmed as they
complete the PCIA-II. Recordings are reviewed by the clinician
and shown to the mother during the four treatment sessions.
The focus of the treatment is working with the mother to identify
difficulties in the parent-child interaction as well as to highlight areas
of parenting strength. Maternal attributions, parenting stress, and parent
perceptions of child behavior problems are assessed for waitlist and treatment groups during pre-treatment, post-treatment and follow-up phases
of the intervention. Treatment efficacy will be assessed through measures
assessing parental attributions, representations, affect, behaviors, and child behavior problems.
Attributions, Affect, and Representations as Mediators of the Relationship Between the Severity of Domestic Violence and Parenting Behaviors.
Kelly Young and Rick Holigrocki This study examines questions about possible mechanisms that underlie the relationship between the severity of domestic violence and negative parenting behaviors. The proposed mediators are attributions, negative affect, and hostile and malevolent representations. Method: Twenty women victims of domestic violence (WVDV) and their 7- to 10-year-old children are being recruited from a domestic violence shelter and a transitional living program. A contrast group of 20 mothers who have children of similar age and gender are being recruited from the community. Dyads are administered a multimethod assessment to assess severity of domestic violence (CTS-2; Conflict Tactics Scale, Straus, Hamby, & Warren, 2003), parenting behaviors (PCIA-II; Parent-Child Interaction Assessment II, Holigrocki, Kaminski, & Frieswyk, 1999, 2002 coded using the AMBIANCE; Atypical Maternal Behavior Instrument for Assessment and Classification, Bronfman, Parsons, & Lyons-Ruth, 2004), attributions (ASQ; Attributional Style Questionnaire, Peterson, Semmel, von Bayer, Abramson, Metalsky, & Seligman, 1982), negative affect (BDI-II; Beck Depression Inventory II, Beck, Steer, & Brown, 1996), and representations (TAT-AT; Thematic Apperception Test, Murray, 1943 scored using SCORS-AT; Social Cognition and Object Relations Scale, Affect Tone, Westen, 1991). Proposed Analysis: This study utilizes a mixed design quasi-experimental method, whereby both groups will be compared on the key constructs and a mediational model will be tested within the women victims of domestic violence (WVDV) group. Implication: Support for a mediational model would provide an empirical rationale for parenting interventions designed to alter WVDV’s attributions, negative affect, and hostile and malevolent representations.